Friday, April 20, 2012

An OOPS and: Cake Batter Pudding Cookies

Who would have thought such a simple recipe could turn into something dangerous?

I found this recipe at The Better Baker blog, and as you know, my mind started racing as to what cake mix flavor, and pudding flavor would go good together. It didn't take me long to put together spice cake, cheese cake pudding and sugared raisins.
The sugared raisins were given to me by my mother. She picked them out of her Raisin Bran cereal. She says they have way too much sugar.....HUH???? Wouldn't it be a lot easier to just buy Bran Flakes cereal? But my mom is the type of person to not waste anything. So, the thoughtful mother that she is, she bagged up those too much sugar raisins and gave them to her food blogging daughter. They were perfect in these cookies. THANKS MOM!!

But this cookie didn't go together as easily as I thought it would. I got confused with the directions because adding the flour was in the directions twice. "Okay food blogger, you know when and where to add the flour."
The confusion with the directions caused me to neglect the ingredient amounts and I dumped in the whole box of cake mix. When I realized my mistake, it was too late to separate the cake mix and pudding from the butter. HA!! If you can accomplish that please let me know how you did it.
So what I did was, I scooped out what I thought was a fair amount, put it in a container, and now it's stored in my frig (since it has butter in it) for future use in cookies.
Then I adjusted the butter amounts added the eggs and vanilla, and then mixed in the flour that the recipe called for.
For an "OOPS" this cookie turned out pretty good.
But of course, I would love to make them the right way to see if they are better.

This recipe has been linked to:

Spice Cake Batter Pudding Cookies

Recipe adapted from: The Better Baker

1 1/2 sticks butter, soft
3/4 c. brown sugar
1/4 c. white sugar
1 pkg (3 oz.) instant pudding (I used cheese cake flavor)
3/4 c. cake mix any flavor (I used spice cake)
2 eggs
1 tsp. vanilla
1 tsp. baking soda
2 1/4 c. flour (I used bread flour)
1/2 tsp. salt
1/2 c. raisins (sugared raisins from Raisin Bran cereal)
I sprinkled the tops of mine with a cinnamon sugar mixture before baking.

Preheat oven to 350 degrees F.
In large bowl, cream butter and sugars together.
In a separate bowl mix flour, baking soda, and salt together; set aside
In another bowl mix 3/4 c. cake mix and the box of instant pudding. Mix together well.
Add the cake mixture to the butter mixture; add eggs and vanilla. Mix until smooth. Add the flour mixture slowly until well blended.
Stir in raisins.
Roll into 1 inch balls and place on cookie sheets. Bake 10-12 minutes.



  1. YUM!! So happy to see you linked this to Weekend Potluck! Enjoy a wonderful weekend...and that new fridge. =)

    1. Thanks Marsha! At least I don't have to worry about my food spoiling anymore. The sound my frig was making, I never knew when it was going to quit.

  2. How many times have I don't something similar? The recipe calls for 1 cup powdered sugar and I'm thinking in my head "1 box powd sugar" and pour in the whole thing? Oy.

    Still can't get over your mom picking out those raisins! But yes, do NOT be wasteful!

    I have tried a few pudding cookie recipes and have been happy with them!


I look forward to and appreciate any comments.
Thank you for stopping by.


2013 (1) Ambrosia (1) Appetizers (23) Apples (2) artichoke (2) Arugula (1) Asparagus (1) Bacon (1) Baking (2) Balsamic Vinegar (3) Bars (18) BBQ (1) Beans (1) Beef (24) Beer (1) Beverage (8) Black Beans (1) Blended Oats (1) Blind Spot Nutbutter (1) Blueberries (1) Bread and Quick Bread (28) Breakfast (18) Buckeyes (1) Caesar Dressing (1) Cake (48) Candy (1) Candy Cane (2) Candy Corn (1) Casing Franks (1) Casserole (1) Celery (1) Cheese (1) cheese ball (1) Cheesecake (1) Cherry (1) Chicken (40) chili (1) Chocolate (2) chocolate chip cookies (2) chocolate chips (1) Christmas (5) Cinnamon (2) coconut (1) Coffee Mate (1) Cookie Butter (1) Cookie Cutters (1) Cookies (45) Cornmeal (1) crackers (1) Cranberries (1) Cranberry Sauce (1) Cream Cheese (2) crescent rolls (1) Crock Pot (5) Cucumber (1) Cut-out Cookies (1) danish (1) Dessert (4) Dry Roasted Peanuts (1) Egg White (1) Eggs (1) Fall (2) feta (1) Fish (5) Foodie Friends Friday (3) French Toast (1) French's Crispy Jalapenos (1) fruit (2) Fudge (1) Garlic (3) Garlic Bread (1) Giveaway (10) Giveaways (3) Greek (1) Green (1) guacamole (1) Holiday (32) Holiday Gifts (1) Jell-O (3) Key Lime (1) Lasagna (1) Link Party (11) linky party (1) liver (1) Low calorie (1) Magazine (1) Marshmallow Fluff (1) Martha White (1) Meat Balls (1) Mediterranean (1) menu (12) Mexican Soup (1) Muffins (23) Mushrooms (3) Nestle Toll House (1) No-Bake (1) Nut Butter (1) Oatmeal (1) Oatmeal Scotchies (1) olives (1) Overnight (1) Parmesan cheese (1) Pasta (5) Peanut Butter (2) Pear (1) Penne (1) Pepperoni (1) Pesto (2) Picnics (1) Pico De Gallo (1) Pie (1) Pie Crust (1) pie filling (1) Pies (9) Pistachios (1) Pizza (1) Points (1) Pork (21) Pork Loin (1) Pot Roast (1) Potato (2) Potluck (1) Pretzel Buns (2) Product Review (1) pumpkin (2) Recipe (62) Recipes (19) Reese's (1) Review (1) Roasted Vegetables (2) salad (2) Salads (46) Sandwiches (16) Sargento Cheese (1) Sausage (1) Side (2) side dish (1) simmer sauce (1) Simple (1) Sliders (1) Snickers (1) Soup (41) spinach (6) Sprinkles (1) squash (1) Stir Fry (1) Strawberry (1) stuffed pepper (1) Stuffing (1) Sugar Free (1) Survival (1) Sweet Baby Ray (1) Taste of Home (2) This and That (120) Tomatoes (3) Trader Joe's (1) Turkey (6) Valentine's Day (1) Vegetables (38) Web Site (1) Weight Watchers (17) White Chocolate (1) wilted (1) Wrap (1)